SXSW Session Recap: The Politics Behind HTML 5

I had a great time at this year’s SXSW Conference. Tried to make it out to as many panels as possible. I missed a few due to the distance between campuses and confusion over shuttle buses — see #2 and #7 on Jim’s post. That said, I did make it a point to check out “The Politics Behind HTML5” panel. Moderated by Charles McCathieNevile (Chief Standards Officer @ Opera), the panel also included:

— John Foliot (Manager Stanford Online Accessibility Program @ Stanford University)
— Paul Cotton (Partner Group Manager @ Microsoft Canada)

All three were World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) representatives.

I wasn’t really interested in learning more about HTML5’s awesomeness, I really wanted to learn why certain things make it into the spec and why some things don’t — and this panel did not disappoint. People attending the panel may not have liked some of the answers presented, but answers we did get.

So, why does the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) care about HTML all of sudden?

Paul Cotton (Microsoft) was very blunt about this and stated that the W3C made a mistake by focusing solely on XML/XHTML. The W3C managed the HTML spec until HTML4, when it decided to cease support and, instead, started building off of the XHTML spec, which was ultimately abandoned in 2009. While all of this was happening, Opera and Mozilla (and later Apple) got together and started a new group called the Web Hypertext Application Technology Working Group (WHATWG) that was focused on enhancing the then abandoned HTML spec. So, now there are actually two organizations involved in developing HTML5: the W3C and the WHATWG. The W3C sees their involvement with HTML5 as an attempt to “bring the prodigal son back into the family.”

How do things get included in the HTML5 spec?

I have a feeling that people assume that specs are written by a closed group of individuals who are somehow detached from the real world. Further, they are written to scratch some obscure itch and, therefore, don’t reflect anything that anyone actually cares about. Or is that just me? To that end, John Foliot (Stanford) kept making the point that if you want to know what will end up in the HTML5 spec, read the front page of the Wall Street Journal.

If TV networks want their content online, that means leveraging the latest and greatest browser technologies, which means that HTML5 will probably end up supporting that. Why? Because NBC/ABC/CBS/CNN/etc have very deep pockets — obviously. You go where the money is.  Foliot made the point that when things like this happen, then very basic user-centric principles, like accessibility, are thrown out the door. To Foliot’s point, things like accessibility can’t be an after-thought or a “feature” — it has to be part of the spec. Otherwise it may never be included, because it’ll be easier to just keep pushing it down the “we’ll get to that later” list. Jeremy Keith (pic below), author of “HTML5 for Web Designers,” also chimed in from the audience and brought up that basic design principles (ie, “put the user first”, etc) may also fall prey to bottom-line thinking.

How do you balance the need to get a workable spec out the door in a timely fashion while ensuring that things like accessibility support are included?  Tough question. I don’t know. Those W3C guys get paid a ton of money to figure stuff like that out (maybe not).

Source: Jeffrey Zeldman

On the topic of TV networks making their content available online (and this goes for movies and music, as well) via HTML5-capable browsers, a question came up regarding Digital Rights Management (DRM). Where/how/when does this get integrated into HTML5? Does it happen within HTML5 via extension points or will there be a single DRM format?  As Cotton said, the use of extension points is a double-edged sword. On the one hand, it absolves the W3C from having to develop DRM support within the spec, which, from an organizational perspective might be a good thing, since it’s one less thing for them to worry about. But if they let 3rd party developers come up with their own formats, we lose the ability to standardize DRM and browsers will then need to support multiple codecs.

There were no clear answers to these questions and scenarios, but we did get an idea of some of the questions that the W3C has to struggle with when deciding what gets included in the spec.  Overall, great panel.

Related Posts

1 Comment
  • hameac2034
    Posted at 02:00h, 05 May

    Ask your sharpener to try it at a few different sizes to determine which one you like air jordan 28 best.In my opinion it’ll nevertheless be less complicated to sell these sorts of merchandise towards the public, as ladies depend on it every day, than expensive super juice stuff, due to the fact that isn’t the common in each and every and each and every household.Nonetheless, taking advantage of the exact very same concepts and reasoning, we can understand the logic behind the multi-brand methods of different markets and business, or we might develop our own methods of approach.If you find out a girl really likes a specific song and you’re at a dance, request that song to the DJ.

    Famed of relaxed feeling, firewire applied within of footwear make it truly versatile that aid as second pores and skin in the ft.L ow fees blended with well-performing support help to make this online pharmacy unequaled along with different online pharmacies.Red is newly produced marrow.Digging out these numbers, like all my stories involving government reports, always are eye-openers and all of my own data mining proves, using the government’s own figures, that the rosy forecasts and the blatherings of our officials running this mess are lies!Visa http://www.Oh, I can’t wait!I’m not sure I am either, horizontal stripes make you look wider because the pattern plays tricks on your eyes.

    Professional credit counselors help people to build a payment strategy to settle a financial situation.While on the pitch, it will be the Kobe’s world, and the followers are so wild about the Kobe’s movements, which will lead a fashion.Then follow these steps to measure your feet:The http://www.zshopshoes.co.uk/nike-zoom-hyperchaos-c-17_20/ principal makers of skating shoes: Some of the principle manufacturers of footwear contain Adio, Zoo York, Etnies, and Lakai.This question gets searched for by women from all four corners of the globe I swear every single day!Much like most plants, if you do not offer your anthurium sufficient water, it’s going to perish.This is based mostly on personal preference even so it have to be mentioned that targets assistance in strengthening your shots.

    This all exists because of the Medicare Drug Part D plan, which was a very expensive program passed under President Bush.And then, get a great hair straightener.The knot is about an inch to the right of my spine or around the upper trapezius or levator scapulae if I am reading the anatomy chart right.Most of the islands towns and villages were established near a beach or at least offer a marina.In the shape of a thick, silicon pad that sits kind of at the top of your cleavage and up over your chest.Beginning online shopping customers chiefly don know where to buy?Whereas Analyze, themself, just didn’t primarily be conscious of the magnitude for Nike’s supply, his adviser, David Falk, spotted your one-time solely chance for Nike’s feature to possess a unique series associated with trainers termed “Air Jordans.

    Subject to this the specific suits tend to be supplemental your painstaking style and design.I didn’t want to sit through the whole video.It seems everyone wants something for nothing and these folks who tell others how to manipulate the system are ruining the Internet tool, which is so very valuable to our civilization.A lot of the participants use high-top experts intended for Nike Basketball Shoes For Sale total ankle joint help.gold north of town repeatedly nods to say: egg, if you the affair that still is different from wants to be busy, you go first favour, my a person at here foolish be.ninety-five% died division, and the remaining five percent were left in the Miluo Ke ?But due to certain management issue the business went bankrupt.

Post A Comment